Our new agency wants to rebuild our Google Ads in a brand-new account. Should we keep the old one?
TofuAnswer by the Tofu team · checked
Usually keep it, and have the agency rebuild the campaigns inside it. The old account holds what a new one lacks: past conversion data (Google says Smart Bidding "never starts from scratch" when an account has some), up to two years of change history, and Customer Match targeting, which needs 90 days of history and more than USD 50,000 lifetime spend. A new account makes sense if you need a different currency or time zone, which can't be changed, or can't get control of the old one. Then pause the old account rather than closing it.
Ask Tofu next
Pick a question and Tofu Ads Agent answers it in chat.
- Does my Google Ads account qualify for Customer Match targeting?
- How do I restructure my Google Ads campaigns without losing conversion history?
- Which of my Google Ads conversion actions should be primary before a new agency takes over?
- Audit my Google Ads account structure and tell me what is worth rebuilding
- How do I keep importing CRM deals for clicks from my old Google Ads account?
As of November 2026.
Rebuild in the old account vs new account with the old one paused vs closed vs both live
A new structure doesn't need a new account. The agency can build new campaigns next to the old ones in the same account, then pause the old ones.
| Rebuild in the old account | New account, old one paused | New account, old one closed | Both accounts live | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Conversion data for Smart Bidding | Kept for the whole account | New account starts with none | New account starts with none | Split across two accounts |
| Customer Match targeting | Kept, if the account qualifies now | Only once the new account has 90 days of history and more than USD 50,000 lifetime spend | The same, and the old account's lists are emptied | The same as a new account |
| Change history and past reports | Up to 2 years, next to the new campaigns | Still in the old account | Only if you reactivate it | Split |
| CRM deals from earlier clicks | Uploaded as now | Uploaded to the old account, which got the clicks | The Google Ads API can't reach a canceled account, and Google's pages don't say whether other upload routes still work | Each account gets its own |
| Main risk | The agency has to work around old names, settings and lists | Google cancels it after more than 15 months with no spend | Google's pages disagree on whether you can always reactivate it | Breaks Google's unfair advantage policy if both show an ad for you in the same spot |
When rebuilding in the old account is the right pick
Most of the time. New campaigns still start without their own history, and Google says new campaigns or bid strategies "lacking historical data may experience temporary performance fluctuations." But it also says, "If you have past conversion data in your account, Smart Bidding never starts from scratch." A new account gives up that head start. For which changes restart learning, see whether budget or target changes restart the learning period.
Keep these in place while the agency rebuilds:
- Conversion actions, especially any that import closed deals from your CRM. Imported conversions must go to the account the click came from (or the manager account that tracks its conversions), and Google keeps the click ID (GCLID) for 90 days.
- Audience and Customer Match lists. Google allows Customer Match targeting and bid adjustments only with 90 days of history and more than USD 50,000 lifetime spend. Its policy says "your account or manager account" must have a good policy and payment history, but it doesn't say whether a manager account's history counts toward the 90-day and USD 50,000 test, so don't plan on it. Exclusions are open to every policy-compliant account; see how to exclude customers and open deals.
- Your own Admin access. See how to keep ownership of your ad accounts.
When a new account with the old one paused is the right pick
When the old account can't do what you need:
- A different currency or time zone. Google says both are "permanently set" when you create an account, so a change needs a new one.
- You can't get control of the old account. That's a different problem: if your previous agency holds it, try taking your Google Ads account back first. A new account is the fallback.
If you go this way:
- Decide who owns the new account. If the agency creates it from its own manager account, that manager "will automatically become the owner." Your company still owns the data and can unlink the manager, but agree on ownership and Admin access first. See which access level to give an agency.
- Copy what's worth keeping. Google Ads Editor can copy or move campaigns between accounts. Pasted items don't keep their performance history, and a campaign on a portfolio bid strategy switches to manual CPC in the other account. Google's help for the web interface says to use Editor between accounts, though it also says a manager account can copy Search campaigns across its linked accounts, only into an account with the same currency. If the new account uses a different currency, Editor keeps the same bid and budget numbers, so check them.
- Keep importing old deals into the old account. Deals from clicks it received have to be imported there, within that 90-day window.
- Share website visitor lists if you need them. A manager account can share them with the owning account's permission, and campaigns using them stop if sharing is turned off.
- Expect a slow start. Google lists account maturity among the factors behind limited ad serving, and bidding has no conversion data yet.
- Map tracking, naming and negative keyword lists before relaunch. They break in any handover; see what breaks when you bring ad accounts in-house.
A paused account keeps its reports, but Google cancels accounts with no spend for more than 15 months. Google's pages then disagree. One says "You'll always be able to reactivate your canceled account." Another says you "may not have the option to reactivate your canceled account after an extended period." Export the reports you want before then.
When closing the old account is the right pick
Rarely, and only after the new account has its own history and you've exported what you want. Once an account is canceled, Google closes its remarketing and Customer Match lists, cuts their membership to one day about a month later, and stops lists it shared from working in other accounts. A canceled account also can't be reached through the Google Ads API until it's reactivated.
When running both accounts is the right pick
Only for a short handover, on different searches. Google's unfair advantage policy, as updated in April 2025, bans "trying to show more than one ad for your business, app, or site in a single ad location." Google gives a warning at least 7 days before suspending an account for it. If both accounts bid on the same keywords, pause one side.
Google's third-party policies also require agencies to "use a separate account for each end-advertiser," so the new account must be yours alone.
Does a new account get around a suspension?
No. If the old account is suspended, Google says "any new accounts that the advertiser tries to create may also be suspended," and recommends getting suspended accounts reinstated first. See how to appeal a Google Ads suspension.
What should we ask the new agency?
- What will a new account give us that a rebuild inside the old one won't?
- Who will own the new account, and whose payment method will pay for it?
- How will CRM deals from the old account's clicks keep reaching Google?
- What will you bid on until the new campaigns have enough conversions?
For judging the agency once it starts, see how to know if your B2B PPC agency is doing a good job.
Sources (16)
- About Smart Bidding learning - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Customer Match policy - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- About change history - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- About your language, number format, time zone, and currency settings - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Manager Accounts (MCC): About ownership of client accounts - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Copy or move campaigns - Google Ads Editor Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Copy and paste campaigns, ad groups, ads, audiences, and keywords - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Fix discrepancies and errors in offline conversion imports - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Manage offline conversions - Google Ads API, checked November 8, 2026
- Manager Accounts (MCC): Share audience segments that include your website visitors and app users - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Limited ad serving - Advertising Policies Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Manage a canceled Google Ads account - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Reactivate a canceled Google Ads account - Google Ads Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Update to the Unfair advantage policy (April 2025) - Advertising Policies Help, checked November 8, 2026
- About Google third-party policies - Advertising Policies Help, checked November 8, 2026
- Google Ads account suspensions overview - Advertising Policies Help, checked November 8, 2026