A PPC agency says our budget will bring in a set number of leads. How do I check whether its forecast is realistic?

TofuAnswer by the Tofu team · checked

A clear glass ball resting on wet sand at sunset, showing the horizon upside down inside it

Rebuild it yourself in Google's Keyword Planner. Ask the agency for its keyword list, cost per click, conversion rate and how many leads it expects sales to accept. Then forecast the same keywords at your budget to check the clicks and cost, and test the conversion rate against your own site's numbers, since that guess moves the lead count most. Performance Planner only works for campaigns already running with at least one conversion. Google bars third parties from promising results "beyond what is reasonably achievable," so a guaranteed lead count is a warning sign.

Ask Tofu next

Pick a question and Tofu Ads Agent answers it in chat.

As of November 2026.

What should I ask the agency to show me?

A lead forecast is a chain of guesses: clicks, then leads, then qualified leads. Ask for each in writing. If the agency can't show its inputs, the number is a sales figure, not a forecast.

InputWhat to ask forHow to check it
KeywordsThe actual list, with match types, by campaignPaste it into Keyword Planner
SettingsLocations, language and daily budget the forecast usedUse the same ones in your plan
Cost per clickThe average it assumedKeyword Planner's forecast at your budget
Clicks a monthThe number, and how it got thereBudget divided by cost per click
Conversion rateThe share of clicks that become leads, and where that figure came fromYour own site and CRM history
What counts as a leadDemo request, contact form, call, or something lighterYour CRM
Qualified shareHow many leads it expects sales to acceptYour CRM
TimingWhich month it expects to hit the numberSee the ramp question below
ChannelsSearch only, or Performance Max, Display or LinkedIn tooKeyword Planner covers Search only

How do I check the clicks and cost in Keyword Planner?

Forecast the agency's keywords at your budget and compare. You need a Google Ads account with billing details entered. You can also ask the agency to share its plan (Keyword Planner has a Share button) so you see the settings it used.

  1. In Google Ads, open Keyword planner from the Tools menu.
  2. Select Get search volume and forecasts, paste the agency's keywords (or upload a CSV file) and submit.
  3. On the plan's Forecasts page, set the same locations, date range and average daily budget the agency used. The bid strategy sits in the Maximize clicks drop-down.
  4. Read the forecast clicks, cost, impressions, clickthrough rate and average cost per click. Open the chart of estimated performance by spend to see where more budget stops buying many more clicks.

Know what the forecast can't do. Google's own caveats:

  • It's based on one week of data, averaged into daily forecasts.
  • It covers the Search Network only. It doesn't forecast Display Network clicks.
  • New accounts get averages. Until your account has history, forecasts use "historical average data for all advertisers."
  • Small areas are less accurate. Expect weaker forecasts if you target a small region.
  • Low forecasts can mean few searches. Google says keywords with very low search volumes aren't forecastable at all, and a low forecast may mean too few searches for your keywords. If a niche B2B list shows little or nothing, that is a finding in itself: there may not be enough searches to buy the clicks the agency promises.

Can Keyword Planner forecast leads too?

Only partly. Google says the forecast can switch from Clicks to Conversions when conversion tracking is on; without it, Google points you to Add conversion metrics to review the options. A lead forecast is clicks times a conversion rate, and that rate is the guess that moves the lead count most.

Your own history beats any default: the share of past ad clicks that became real leads (demo requests and contact forms, not newsletter signups). With no history, use a range, not one number.

For context only, LocaliQ's 2026 search advertising benchmarks (updated June 1, 2026, from its customers' Google Ads and Microsoft Ads campaigns) put the average conversion rate at 8.18% across industries, and Business Services at 4.85% with $93.69 per lead. LocaliQ counts a lead as anyone who clicks an ad and then calls, chats, fills in a form or emails, not a lead your sales team accepts, and the report has no software category. Treat them as a rough check, not a target.

When can I use Performance Planner instead?

Only when you already run campaigns. Performance Planner forecasts existing campaigns. For Search and Performance Max, a campaign must have no bid strategy change in the last 10 days, at least 3 clicks and 10 impressions, at least 1 conversion or conversion value, and spend in the last 17 days.

Its forecasts refresh daily from the last 7 to 10 days, adjusted for seasonality. It projects monthly and quarterly results for a conversion goal you choose, counting the conversion actions set as primary. Since March 9, 2026 it no longer plans Display or Video campaigns, or plans built on impression share.

Campaigns that don't qualify can go into a plan only if someone types in their past cost and conversions, so the plan is only as good as those numbers.

So:

  • New account: Keyword Planner is the tool. Performance Planner has nothing to forecast from.
  • Existing account, agency wants more budget: ask it to show you a Performance Planner plan for the extra spend (it's in the Tools menu). Check that the plan's conversion goal is a real lead, not a page view.

How do I test the number backward?

Work out the conversion rate the promise needs, then ask if it's believable. These are made-up numbers, not benchmarks.

StepExample
Agency's promise40 leads a month from $3,000
Implied cost per lead$3,000 ÷ 40 = $75
Keyword Planner's average cost per click at that budget$9
Clicks the budget buys$3,000 ÷ $9 = about 333
Conversion rate the promise needs40 ÷ 333 = 12%
If sales accepts 1 lead in 410 qualified leads, $300 each

A 12% rate is well above LocaliQ's averages, so in this example you'd ask what counts as a lead and why the agency expects it. To carry the math on from qualified leads to customers and payback, use the funnel table on whether Google Ads is worth it for B2B SaaS.

Which assumptions should I push back on?

  • What counts as a lead. If newsletter signups, page views or very short calls count, the conversion rate looks better than your pipeline will.
  • Your own brand searches. People who search your company name convert well and cheaply. A forecast that mixes them in flatters the new-buyer keywords. Ask for brand and non-brand separately.
  • Month one. A forecast that hits its number in the first month ignores the learning period. Ask for a month-by-month ramp. How to judge an agency's first 90 days covers what's normal.
  • Other channels. Keyword Planner covers Search only. Ask for Performance Max, Display or LinkedIn as separate lines.
  • One number. Ask for a low and a high case, such as cost per click 30% higher and conversion rate a third lower. If the low case doesn't work for you, the deal doesn't either.
  • Return on spend. Claims like "$6,000 back from $1,500" depend on your deal size and close rate, which the agency doesn't control. Ask which ones it used.
  • The budget itself. If your budget buys only a few hundred clicks a month, the forecast has little to stand on. See Google Search or LinkedIn first on a small budget.

Is a guaranteed number of leads a red flag?

Yes. Google's third-party policy bans "assuring outcomes that imply guaranteed success or performance beyond what is reasonably achievable," and says this applies "even if such results are technically possible but not typical." A forecast with stated inputs is normal. A guarantee isn't.

Get the forecast, its inputs and the fee in writing: Google's advertiser guide tells you to "get an official copy of your agreement in writing." For the other warning signs, and how to judge results once you've hired, see how to know if your B2B PPC agency is doing a good job.

Where Tofu fits

Tofu Ads Agent (our product) does Google Search keyword research from your site, CRM deals and account history, checked against Keyword Planner volumes and forecasts, the same data you can check yourself. It also audits conversion tracking. It doesn't guarantee a number of leads, and it can't make a thin keyword market bigger. It costs a flat $2,500 per month, not a percentage of spend, with a recommended media budget of at least $3,000 per month.

Sources (8)

Related resources