Google Ads consultant vs agency: when coaching beats management

TofuAnswer by the Tofu team · checked

A line of yellow disc cones laid out across a grass field for a training drill.

Coaching beats an agency when someone on your team has time to run Google Ads every week and you run one or two channels. You pay for a few expert hours, and the skills stay with you. A build-and-hand-over project fits when the account needs building or rebuilding but your marketer can run it afterwards. Hire an agency when nobody in-house has the hours, you run several channels or you need a lot of new creative. A coach needs only Read only access; a consultant building campaigns needs Standard.

Ask Tofu next

Pick a question and Tofu Ads Agent answers it in chat.

As of November 2026.

Coaching vs build and hand over vs agency management

Coaching retainerBuild and hand overAgency runs the account
Who does the daily workYour marketerThe consultant during the project, then your marketerThe agency
What the expert doesReviews the account on a schedule, answers questions, sets prioritiesBuilds or fixes campaigns and tracking, documents them, trains your marketerPlans, builds, runs and reports
Google Ads access the expert needsRead only, or none on a screen shareStandard during the project, then Read only or noneStandard, with Admin kept by your team
How it's pricedHours or sessionsA project priceA share of ad spend or a flat monthly fee
Time from your teamSeveral hours a week, plus callsHigh at handover, then several hours a weekApprovals and a monthly review
What you keepThe skills and the accountA documented account and a trained marketerThe account, if you own it
Main limitWorks only if your marketer has the time and does the workThe account drifts if nobody checks in after handoverUsually the highest outside fee, and the know-how stays with the agency

What does a coaching retainer include?

A good one is written down before it starts. Ask for:

  • A regular account review, every week or two: search terms, conversion tracking, bids and budgets.
  • A review of what your marketer changed since the last call. Your marketer can walk through Change history in the Campaigns menu, which lists changes from the past 2 years and who made each one.
  • A short written priority list after each call, so your marketer knows what to do next.
  • Questions answered between calls, with a stated reply time.
  • A second opinion on big moves, such as a new campaign type or bid strategy, before your marketer makes them.

What it usually leaves out: making the changes, writing ads, building landing pages and reporting to your leadership. If you want any of those, put them in the agreement.

What does coaching cost compared with an agency?

Few advisers we found publish prices. One who does, PPC coach Sarah Stemen, lists a one-hour call at $350 and a 90-day in-house program at "Custom Quote (Starting at $3,000+)" on her 2026 page. That program fixes the account and tracking in the first 30 days, tests ads, audiences and bidding in the next 30, and documents processes and trains your team in the last 30. That is one person's price list, not a market rate.

Agency and freelancer management costs at three spend levels are in the alternatives to a PPC agency, and how many hours a retainer buys shows what a management fee pays for.

To compare the options for your own account, leave the ad spend out: it's the same in every option. Add two numbers for each:

  1. The outside fee for a month.
  2. Your team's time: the hours a month your marketer spends on the account, times what an hour of their time costs you.

Coaching usually has the lowest outside fee and the most in-house time. An agency is usually the reverse. If your marketer can't find the hours, coaching saves nothing, because the work doesn't get done.

Which access does the adviser need?

Give a coach Read only. Google says Read only can view campaigns and planning tools and run campaign performance and billing reports, but can't edit campaigns or billing. That's enough to advise, and the coach can't change anything by mistake. A coach can also work from a screen share with no access at all.

Give a consultant who builds campaigns Standard for the project. Standard can edit campaigns but can't manage users, manager links or payment methods. When the project ends, an Admin on your side can switch them back to Read only: in Access and security (in the Admin menu), hover over their level in the Access level column and pick a new one. The full comparison of levels is on which access level to give an agency or freelancer.

When a coaching retainer is the right pick

When a build-and-hand-over project is the right pick

  • The account is new, or messy enough that fixing it would take your marketer months.
  • Conversion tracking isn't set up, or doesn't connect to your CRM.
  • Your marketer can run campaigns but hasn't built an account from scratch.

Ask for a written handover: the campaign structure, naming rules, each conversion action and what it counts, and a check-in 30 days later. If you already have an agency and are hiring in-house, ask whether it will move to an advisory role for a smaller fee.

When an agency is the right pick

  • Nobody in-house has the hours, or the person who did has left.
  • You run several channels at once, each with its own formats and bidding.
  • You need a steady flow of new ads, images or video.
  • You want one outside team to be accountable for the work getting done.

If you choose an agency, see whether a B2B-only agency is worth it.

Other options people mix up with these

Sources (4)

Related resources