Should I pay an independent PPC consultant to review the account my agency runs, and what should that audit cost?

TofuAnswer by the Tofu team · checked

Often yes, before you renew the agency or raise the budget. Prices published by four sellers run from about $300 to $3,500 or more for a one-off audit. No ad platform sets a rate. It also helps when results drop and the agency's explanation doesn't add up. Free audits from rival agencies are pitches written to win your account. Pay when the fee is small next to the spend at stake. Give the auditor Read only access, ask for findings ranked by money at stake, and let your agency answer in writing.

Ask Tofu next

Pick a question and Tofu Ads Agent answers it in chat.

As of November 2026.

Free agency audit vs paid independent audit vs your own check vs audit software

Free audit from another agencyPaid independent auditYour own check with Google's toolsAudit softwareTofu Ads Agent (our product)
Who does itAn agency that wants to run your accountA consultant paid for the review onlyYou or your teamA tool running set checksAn AI agent that runs campaigns
CostFreeAbout $300 to $3,500 or more, one-off (examples below)Free, plus your timePaid subscriptionFlat $2,500 a month, not a one-off fee
Whose interestWinning your accountYours, if it isn't bidding for the workYoursFixed rules, no stakeRunning your campaigns
Sees which leads became pipelineOnly if you share CRM dataOnly if you share CRM dataIf you pull it from your CRMNot unless you add that dataConnects to HubSpot or Salesforce
Access it needsRead onlyRead only, plus GA4 if you use itYour own loginA connection to the accountYour ad accounts and CRM
Main limitWritten to sell, so it stresses problemsQuality varies, and it costs moneyTakes time and Google Ads know-howCan't tell a mistake from a judgement callNot an independent review of your agency

What does an independent PPC audit cost?

No ad platform publishes a rate, so here are sellers' own list prices, checked November 9, 2026. They are examples of the range, not recommendations.

SellerPublished priceWhat the page says you get
MB Advertising$297, one-offA written review, a video walkthrough and a 30-minute call, covering Google Ads, Meta Ads, GA4 and tracking; 3 to 5 working days from read-only access
Stevie Morris (UK)£450, one-offA written report rating each finding by impact and effort, with a prioritized fix list; within 5 working days of read-only access
Orr ConsultingFrom $3,500, flat feeA written review, prioritized fixes, a conversion tracking check and a Performance Max review; the base price covers up to 5 campaigns and 12 months of history
Doctor Ads (UK)£5,000, fixedA one-week examination, per its own list of audit firms (updated October 31, 2026)

Pricing works differently by seller. Orr Consulting's fee rises with the number of campaigns and the months of history reviewed, not with ad spend; MB Advertising charges the same whether it reviews one platform or several. Ask whether a call to walk through the findings is included.

How much to spend is a judgement call. Our rule of thumb, not a standard: the audit should cost less than the waste it could plausibly find in two or three months. At $5,000 a month in spend, 10% waste is $500 a month, so a $300 to $500 review is in proportion. A $3,500 audit fits a bigger account or a bigger decision, such as renewing a long contract.

When a free agency audit is the right pick

When you're already shopping for a new agency. Read two or three side by side: the questions each one asks about your goals and lead quality tell you more than its list of faults. Treat each one as a sales document. An agency that wants your account has a reason to make the current one look bad. Give Read only access, don't share your contract or fees, and remove the access when you're done.

When a paid independent audit is the right pick

When the decision is big enough to pay for an outside view:

  • Before you renew the agency or sign a longer term. See what exit terms are normal in a PPC agency contract.
  • Before you raise the budget on the agency's advice.
  • When results fall and the agency's explanation doesn't add up.
  • When nobody in-house can read the account.

It's usually too early in a new agency's first 30 to 60 days; you can check the setup yourself first (see how to know if your B2B PPC agency is doing a good job). Before you hire, ask the consultant whether they would bid to run the account afterward, ask for a sample report, and ask who does the work.

When your own check with Google's tools is the right pick

When spend is small, or you want to know what to ask before paying anyone. Google's Recommendations page, optimization score and Ads Advisor are free inside the account, but they show what Google would change, not whether leads became revenue. Our page on AI tools that audit a Google Ads account covers them and what to check first.

When audit software is the right pick

When you run several accounts or want an alert the day something breaks. Adalysis and Optmyzr are paid subscriptions with built-in account checks (Adalysis lists more than 100). They don't know your sales cycle and can't judge whether your agency's choices were sensible. The AI audit tools page compares them.

When Tofu Ads Agent (our product) is the right pick

When the real question is whether to keep paying an agency at all. Tofu plans, builds and runs LinkedIn, Google Search, Google Display and Meta campaigns in your own ad accounts, including a conversion tracking audit for Google Search, for a flat $2,500 a month (recommended media budget at least $3,000 a month). Campaigns are staged switched off and launch only when a person turns them on. It isn't a neutral second opinion on your agency's work.

How do I brief the auditor?

Give them what the account can't show:

  • Your goal, such as cost per qualified lead or pipeline from paid search.
  • What counts as qualified, and the last 90 days of CRM outcomes for ad leads.
  • What the agency is paid to do, from your contract.
  • Your budget history and any big changes you asked for.
  • The questions you want answered, such as "Is our spend going to the right searches?"

For access, add the auditor in Google Ads at Read only. Google says Read only can view campaigns and use planning tools, run campaign performance and billing reports, and see users, managers and product links, but can't edit campaigns. That's enough to audit and can't break anything. The full comparison of levels is on which Google Ads access level an agency or freelancer should get.

What should a good audit deliver?

  • Findings ranked by money at stake, each with evidence from your account.
  • Clear errors kept apart from judgement calls. A misspelled company name or broken tracking is an error. Match types or bidding choices may be a fair difference of opinion.
  • Conversion tracking checked first. If junk counts as a lead, every other number is off.
  • What the agency actually did. Change history lists the past 2 years of changes, and its User column shows the email of whoever made each change in the Google Ads interface. The search terms report shows the real searches behind your clicks, though Google leaves out some terms for privacy.
  • What the agency does well, so you don't undo good work.
  • A fix list with an order and an owner for each item.

How do I share the results with my agency?

Send the findings and ask for a written reply by a set date: what it agrees with, what it disputes and why, and when it will make each fix. Agree on two or three numbers to recheck in 30 to 60 days. If the auditor should make fixes too, give them Standard access for a set period, then switch back. If the agency won't engage with clear errors, that tells you more than the audit itself.

Sources (10)

Related resources